Neugebauer joined the Towson football team as the offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach starting in the 2025 season.
He comes to Towson after two years at the offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach at McNeese State University, helping the team improve five victories from 2023 to 2024. His 2024 team led the Southland Conference in rushing yards a game (18th in FCS), finishing with 2,300 on the year, adding over 2,300 yards passing. He also ran and organized the program's alumni golf outing for two years, raising over $100,000.
He also served as offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach at East Tennessee State in 2022, Slippery Rock from 2019-2021 and Tiffin from 2015-2016. His 2019 and 2021 Slippery Rock team combined to go 22-4 while averaging 42.8 points and 491 yards per game, including 95 passing touchdowns. In 2019, Slippery Rock's offense scored a combined 647 points, 7,000 total offensive yards and 89 touchdowns, being the second-ranked passing offense in the country. Quarterback Roland Rivers III earned the Harlon Hill Award, given to the top player in DII, and was later signed to rookie camp with the Pittsburgh Steelers in the NFL. Rivers also played in the United States Football League with the Pittsburgh Maulers.
Neugebauer also was the quarterbacks coach at Georgetown University from 2017-18, working alongside current Towson offensive line assistant Alex Kolt. He was at Tiffin from 2012-16, going from graduate assistant running backs coach/equipment manager to quarterbacks coach and later offensive coordinator. From 2015-16 at Tiffin as the offensive coordinator, each team averaged over 33 points per game, including going 8-3 in 2016, the school's winningest season in the program's D2 history. Tiffin quarterback Antonio Pipkin, who finished with over 10,000 passing yards, was one of two DII quarterbacks ever signed to play in the Senior Bowl, signed with the Arizona Cardinals in the NFL and played eight seasons in the Canadian Football League.
He has had two stints with USA Football (2014, 2017) and was a volunteer football coach at North Allegheny Intermediate School in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania in 2012.
Neugebauer was the 2011 D2 Quarterback of the Year, Harlon Hill finalist and a first team All-American at West Virginia Wesleyan College, being inducted into the school's Hall of Fame in 2024. The walk-on turned scholarship player broke 28 school records, including throwing for 4,111 yards and 40 touchdowns in 2011. Post-graduation, he was the MVP of the Hanson Bowl and played professionally in Arena Football for the Green Bay Blizzard and Marion Blue Racers.
Neugebauer graduated from West Virginia Wesleyan in 2012 with a degree in criminal law/political science. He is married to Lindsay Neugebauer.
